In 2024, under Biden government, USA said hatred speech decreased in Brazil out of Bolsonaro; Compare the reports

Under Trump, US Human Rights Report criticizes Moraes and Lula government The US State Department states that the human rights situation in Brazil “deteriorated” between 2024 and 2023, according to the report published on Tuesday (12). The document, written by the management of Donald Trump, nominally criticizes the president of Brazil, Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, and the Supreme Court Minister Alexandre de Moraes. The main focus of criticism is the topic “Freedom of Expression and the Press”. ✅ Click here to follow the G1 international news channel on WhatsApp Tom is quite different from the last report published in the management of Trump’s predecessor, Democrat Joe Biden. The 2024 document, on the situation of Brazil in 2023, even states that freedom of the press had an improvement, and attacks on journalists decreased by the departure of Jair Bolsonaro from the presidency. The very concept of “hate speech” is treated in different ways in both texts. See below for the main differences between Biden and Trump reports: freedom of expression and Biden Management The Biden government report states that Brazilian Constitution and law provided for freedom of expression, including members of the press and other media, and that the government generally respected this right. He notes that independent media, an effective judiciary and a functional democratic political system combined to promote freedom of expression. One point cited as positive for freedom was Jair Bolsonaro’s departure from the presidency, which “verbally attacking journalists and press vehicles.” Trump management in a remarkable contrast, the 2024 report begins by stating that “the situation of human rights in Brazil worsened during the year,” and immediately highlights issues related to freedom of expression and freedom on the internet. Made by an allied government of Jair Bolsonaro and his family, the Tuesday’s report claims that the Brazilian judiciary has taken “broad and disproportionate measures to undermine freedom of expression and internet freedom” by blocking the access of millions of users to information on an important social networking platform. ” There are specific mentions to Alexandre de Moraes and the blockade of social network X, as well as the blockade of accounts on different social networks accused of spreading misinformation. Trump and Biden Saul Loeb, Elijah Nouvelage / AFP Hate Discourse Biden Management The 2024 report by Biden management uses the concept of hate speech objectively. He points to the topic as a concern for his dissemination on social networks: “The broad use of social media has facilitated the online hate speech against journalists, citizens and institutions.” Trump Management The Trump Management 2025 report, in turn, questions the expression, calling the term “broad”, “vagus” and “ambiguous”. According to the document published on Tuesday, the Brazilian government “suppressed politically unfavorable speeches based on the fact that they constitute ‘hate discourse’, a vague and detached term of international human rights law.” Analysis: Trump tests presidential power and borders on the authoritarianism biden management without deepening, the 2024 report talks about the criminalization of Nazism and cites the arrest of neo -Nazi cell members as an advance in combating anti -Semitism. Trump Management The 2025 report claims that there was “a sharp increase” in cases of anti -Semitism in Brazil after the Hamas terrorist attack to Israel in October 2023, especially in digital environments. The document also cites comparisons between Holocaust and the Israeli War against Hamas in the Gaza Strip made by Lula, convicted of pro-Israel organizations, such as Conib (Israelite Confederation of Brazil). Nevertheless, there are positive mentions to the dismantling of neo -Nazi cells in the country. About the report that is the document released by the US: the “Human Rights Practice Report in 2024” was handed over to the US Congress. It consists of evaluations from 196 United Nations Member Countries (UN) and is a world reference – for example, in US and international courts. The report is disclosed annually. ✅ Trump Context: The Human Rights Report on Brazil vocalizes Trump -like criticisms since it has announced a tariff to Brazilian products. Justifying the fare, Trump quoted political persecution to former President Bolsonaro, his ally. The report shows a change in relation to O disclosed in 2024, made under the administration of Joe Biden (Democratic Party), Trump’s rival. Polychização Polytization: The Washington Post newspaper reported that the newsroom of the report on Brazil caused “discomfort” in the state department, with servers saying that “the process was unduly politicized” when compared to previous years.

Source link