The Trump administration filed an appeal Tuesday after a judge ordered slavery exhibits that were removed from the President’s House Site in Philadelphia to be returned.
In a ruling issued Monday, Senior Judge Cynthia M. Rufe ordered the defendants in the case — Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum, the Department of the Interior, National Park Service Acting Director Jessica Bowron and the National Park Service — to restore the site to the way it was on Jan. 21, the day before the signage was removed. They also must keep all of the items safe, secure and undamaged, and cannot install any “replacement materials” without mutual agreement with the city of Philadelphia while the litigation is ongoing or before another order from the judge.
The order also says officials must continue to properly maintain the site, including the grounds, video monitors, recordings and exhibits. The order does not give NPS a deadline for restoring the site.
Monday’s order grants the city’s latest motion for a preliminary injunction and will be in effect until the judge issues another ruling.
The exhibits in question provide information about enslaved people who lived at the site with Presidents George Washington and John Adams. After Park Service workers removed the signs in January, the city of Philadelphia filed a lawsuit in federal court seeking to have the displays put back. The suit argues that the city has prior agreements with NPS that require any disputes to be resolved through communication and compromise between the two parties.
Rufe begins her memo about the opinion with a quote from the George Orwell novel “1984” and says the court has been asked “to determine whether the federal government has the power it claims— to dissemble and disassemble historical truths when it has some domain over historical facts.”
She continues: “It does not.”
The Interior Department said in a statement Monday that it disagrees with the court’s ruling.
“The National Park Service routinely updates exhibits across the park system to ensure historical accuracy and completeness. If not for this unnecessary judicial intervention, updated interpretive materials providing a fuller account of the history of slavery at Independence Hall would have been installed in the coming days,” the statement says.
A spokesperson with the Interior Department said in a statement in January that the displays were removed as the department implements President Trump’s executive order “Restoring Truth and Sanity to American History.”
Philadelphia Mayor Cherelle Parker called the order “a huge win” in a video posted on social media Tuesday.
“This summer, Philadelphia will lead a litany of semiquincentennial celebrations in honor of America’s 250th birthday, and please know that we will do so with a great deal of pride, a pride that comes from acknowledging all of our history and all of our truth, no matter how painful it may be. It will be the truth when it’s told accurately. We will not allow anyone to erase our history,” Parker said.
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro and the counties surrounding Philadelphia have backed the city in the suit. Community groups have also organized protests and rallies calling for the signs to be restored.
In a statement, Rep. Brendan Boyle, who represents Philadelphia in Congress, said, “I strongly opposed the Trump Administration’s decision to remove these exhibits, and I welcome the federal court’s ruling that they must be restored. … I will continue fighting to ensure these exhibits are fully restored and accessible to the public.”
Rep. Dwight Evans said on social media, “This is a victory for all Philadelphians and Americans over a shameful attempt by the Trump-Vance administration to whitewash our history.”
Supporters say fight isn’t over
The judge’s order came as dozens of people were gathered — on Presidents Day — to rally for the panels to be put back.
“Better than fighting the good fight is winning the good fight. And today, we won,” Michael Coard with the Avenging the Ancestors Coalition said.
“I felt that it was a horrible thing that they would take our history down. I think it’s everybody’s history,” said Glenn Kutler, of Center City, during the rally.
The federal government’s appeal could keep the displays down longer. In the meantime, some have started putting up their own signs. Still, he said, he’s optimistic.
“This tells me that there’s some glimmer of hope for the future of America,” Coard said.
CBS News Philadelphia
