This Friday (13), Minister Flávio Dino voted for the decision that made it impossible to break confidentiality approved by the Joint Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry of the National Institute of Social Service (CPMI of the INSS). The magistrate was the first to vote for the injunction to be maintained. The measure ended up benefiting President Lula’s son, “Lulinha”.
In the decision being analyzed, Dino suspended measures approved jointly by the CPMI of the INSS that authorized the breaking of banking and tax secrecy of those investigated in the case of irregular discounts on benefits for the organization’s retirees and pensioners. Among the targets of these measures is Fábio Luís Lula da Silva, known as Lulinha.
When voting for the decision, Dino stated that it is not appropriate to exclude constitutional rights collectively, with votes carried out as a block, without there being an individualized analysis of each case, in addition to adequate debate and a reasoned justification for the decision.
The process was being analyzed in the virtual plenary of the STF by ten ministers. However, Minister Gilmar Mendes presented a prominent request, a mechanism that suspends the trial in the virtual environment and transfers the analysis of the case to the Court’s in-person plenary.
As a result, voting was interrupted before the scheduled deadline. Ministers could register their votes in the electronic system until next Friday.
Currently, the court has a vacant seat after the retirement of minister Luís Roberto Barroso.
