Case Juliana Marins: Experts list possible mistakes before and after the volcano accident in Indonesia

Montanarist fell from a cliff and was found dead three days later. Experts point out driving failures, absence of mandatory equipment and delay in rescue as critical factors. Reports of mountaineers who trail of volcano in Indonesia where Juliana Marins died of the death of 26 -year -old Brazilian Marins, after falling from a cliff on Mount Rinjani, Indonesia, caused a commotion and raised doubts about safety conditions on high -risk international trails. Juliana disappeared on Saturday (21), after separating from the group of five tourists who climbed the trail together. His body was only located on Tuesday (24), more than 600 meters below the trail. Specialists in mountaineering, experienced guides and tourists who have been on site point out serious flaws that may have contributed to the tragedy. Here are the main points under question. Juliana Marins was found dead in a volcano trail; Monte Rinjani, in Indonesia, in a photo of December 2014 Skyseeker/Flickr/Creative Commons Lack of security equipment according to people who have already made the Mount Rinjani trail, the place does not require tourists to take basic safety and protection items such as thermal blankets, coat or gloves. The triathlete, biologist and climbing Isabel Leone, who was on Mount Rinjani ten years ago, recalled that in Brazil, mountain races require this type of equipment. “There is no obligation of emergency equipment. Today you do any tests here in Itatiaia, you have to take blanket, coat, glove, hat. There (Indonesia) no, they require nothing,” said Leone. Juliana Marins, the tourist group and the local guide (in the foreground) at the beginning of the Indonesian track reproduction social networks on the trail people who were with Juliana on the trail say she felt tired on the second day of climbing and asked to rest. However, the guide continued with the others and only returned minutes later, according to information from the Brazilian family. At the fantastic, the 20-year-old guide Ali Musthofa said he was only three minutes ahead of Juliana and returned to search her up to the Brazilian delay. Experts warn that on high -risk trails, the group must walk along all the time, under direct visual supervision of the guide. “The attitude of the guide to separate from one participant or another is incorrect. If they started in groups, they need to end in group. Everyone needs to maintain eye contact and guidance by the most experienced person in the group, which in this case was the guide,” explained mountaineer Aretha Duarte. Silvio Neto, president of the Brazilian Association of Mountain and Mountain Guides for over 25 years, reinforced the need for constant monitoring. “Ideally, it should not be alone, always supported. (…) The ideal is always to keep the group together. But we know that even small groups are heterogeneous,” said Silvio. Who was Juliana Marins, a Brazilian killed in Indonesia for mountaineers like Aretha Duarte, allowing the trail to be alone was a serious failure. Even with different rhythms, it is up to the guide to adapt the slowest walk and ensure the safety of all. “If it’s not possible everyone to keep their pace stronger, everyone needs to follow the slowest pace to follow together and safely,” Duarte added. Lack of guides reports of those who have been there to that many guides walk barefoot, without proper thermal protection, taking little water and food. This information raises suspicion about the quality of the formation of local guides. According to experts, this shows a structural unpreparedness of tourist activity in the region. “The precariousness of the guides there is great. Several walking barefoot. (…) Taking absurd weight, little water, little food,” said Leone. Guides in Indonesia walk barefoot, without adequate thermal protection, taking little water and food, tourists say. Reproduction TV Globo Unstable land and extreme climate Mount Rinjani, with 3,721 meters of altitude, is known for its risks. Since 2020, Monte Rinjani National Park has recorded 190 accidents, with 9 dead and 180 injured, including 44 foreigners. The trail to reach the top of the mountain passes steep areas with loose sand, large stones and dangerous slopes. The weather changes quickly, with intense cold, sudden rains and low visibility. “It’s a lot of rain, intense cold and very traumatic conditions. The weather changed very fast. It rained, tent dragged. He charges a lot from you,” said Claudio Carneiro, a cameraman who was on Mount Rinjani, for the recording of the Extreme Planet program. “I felt very cold, my fingers almost frozen, hard, and I started to get sick, that dust, I had to put a yoke on my nose. And I said I will not, I do not want to sit here,” added Isabel Leone. The Planet Extreme Program team was on Mount Rinjani, with 3,721 meters altitude. Reproduction TV Globo, remembering her experience on the spot, Leone assessed that she could have had the same destination as Juliana. “It’s a beautiful, amazing place, so it attracts so many people. But this tour attracts people without experience, like me at the time. Today I see the risk I spent. I look at her story, moved me a lot and see the risk I went through,” he said. Slow and disorganized rescue although a drone located Juliana on Saturday, she was only reached by rescuers three later. Experts point out that lost time may have been crucial to their survival. “Time can really make a difference between life and death. If the team is unable to rescue immediately, it is necessary to trigger local authorities, firefighters, embassy, ​​travel insurance,” said Aretha Duarte. Juliana became more than 24 hours missing in the canyon. The searches were only completed on the 4th day of operation. Rescue team prepares to continue the search of Brazilian Reproduction TV Globo according to reports, one of the main problems faced by the rescue teams on the first day of searching was the lack of strings with enough length to reach where she was. At that moment, Juliana was about 300 meters from the trail and the rope that the team took to the place was half of this size. The planning failure gets worse, due to the distance between the rescue point and the base of the mountain, which was traveled in about 6 hours. Mismatched information Another serious problem was the confusion in the disclosure of information, which made Juliana’s family members more desperate. Initially, it was reported that Juliana had received water and food, but the Brazilian family and the Brazilian ambassador denied the information the next day. The communication was considered confusing and not transparent by all who accompanied at a distance. Late and limited use of drones technology were used, including with thermal camera, but the operation could not accurately locate it. Many people in Brazil questioned social networks the lack of effectiveness in the use of technology. The situation raises questions about the technical preparation of local rescue teams. Responsibility of the hired agency experts remind you that the company hired by Juliana had civil liability about the accident and should have taken quick steps, including emergency support and activation of authorities. “There is a civil liability inherent in the activity. It was important that the agency had responsibility for the accidents regarding the accident, as soon as possible,” said Aretha. “She hired an agency and a guide, she was surely considering receiving guidance and a support network for experienced people, sufficiently certified so that they could offer security,” said the professional mountaineer. Rescue teams run against time to rescue 26 -year -old Brazilian publicist Juliana Marins, who crashed during a trail on Mount Rinjani, Indonesia Personal Archives Diplomatic and Logistics Obstacles Juliana tried to travel to Indonesia to follow the search, but faced delays due to the closing of airspace in Qatar, because of the conflict between Israel, the Brazilian government. Support, but the distance made it difficult to articulate actions to accelerate the rescue. Click Click here and follow the profile of RJ1 on Instagram ✅ Signs the G1 Rio channel on WhatsApp and receive news from the great river direct on your mobile!

Source link